Gareth
Jones
The Silence of the Sheep
“But
Soviet propaganda, fed by the party
activists who were imbued with a religious fervour, so impressed foreign
visitors and delegates that the outside world was unaware of the
catastrophe that had befallen 90% of the Russian people.”[]
Alas! You will be very amused to hear
that the inoffensive little 'Joneski' has achieved the dignity of being a
marked man on the black list of the O.G.P.U. and is barred from entering the
Soviet Union. I hear that there is a long list of crimes which I have
committed under my name in the secret police file in Moscow and funnily
enough espionage is said to be among them. As a matter of fact Litvinoff
[Soviet Foreign Minister] sent a special cable from Moscow to the Soviet
Embassy in London to tell them to make the strongest of complaints to Mr.
Lloyd George about me.[ii]
Why,
after his final article on April 20th 1933,[iii]
one of at least 20, did Gareth write no further newspaper exposés in Britain
about the plight of the Ukrainians and the man-made famine in the Soviet
Union. Why, in the Daily Express,[iv]
did he write a valedictory, “Goodbye Russia”[v].
As to whether he was silenced there are many unanswered questions. It is as
though the powers that-be wished to airbrush his memory out of history.
Why was his name not mentioned by his eminent contemporaries or recorded in
their archives?
Gareth’s disappointment must have been very great when he realised that he
would never return to Russia and Ukraine again. He had spent his University
years studying Russian culture, literature and the language. The summer of
1927 he stayed in Riga with a Russian family to perfect his pronunciation of
the language, he was a protégé and friend of the eminent Sir Bernard Pares,[vi]
the expert on Soviet Russia and Gareth knew Prince Mirsky and had read his
classic book A History of Russian Literature: From Its
Beginnings to 1900. No young man in
Britain in 1933 was better qualified to speak on the Soviet Union.
His
mother Mrs Annie Gwen Jones had recounted many stories of her happy days in
Hughesovka when he was a child. She had lived the life of a well-born
Russian and despite a luxurious life, she had a great concern for the less
fortunate Russian people. She sympathised with ideals of the educated
nihilists who demanded better social conditions though not with their
criminal methods used to carry out their aims. She wrote of her concern for
the Mujaks, the peasants; for the harsh treatment of the Jews and the
suppression of the Polish people. Her love of Ukraine and her high moral
principles she instilled into her son, Gareth. She, too, would have been
moved to hear of the heart-rending plight of the starving Ukrainians.
Though on the black list of the Soviet Secret police and accused of
espionage, Gareth did not lack courage. In the autumn of 1933, despite being
barred from writing articles in British newspapers, he lectured in Britain
and Ireland on the Enigma of Bolshevik Russia. In 1930 he had written to his
mother: “I should consider myself a flabby little coward if I ever gave up
the chance of a good and interesting career for the mere thought of
safety. … I have come to the conclusion that the only life I can live
with interest and which I can really be of use is one connected with
foreign affairs and with men and women of today; …Why do you
want a son of yours to have no courage.
Gareth’s treatment at the hands of his journalist colleagues is well
documented. He returned to Berlin from the Soviet Union
and on March 29th 1933 Gareth immediately issued a press release
to the world, describing the terrible genocide-famine in Ukraine brought
about by Stalin’s policy of Collectivization and Industrialization, known
today as the Holodomor
This
press release was first published on the 29th of March 1933,
by H.R.Knickerbocker,[vii]
the German correspondent for New York Evening Post Foreign Service,
and he wrote that ‘Mr. Jones’, “who spoke Russian
fluently, was the first foreigner to visit the Russian countryside since the
Moscow authorities forbade foreign correspondents to leave the city. Famine
on a colossal scale, impending death of millions from hunger, murderous
terror and the beginnings of serious unemployment in a land that had
hitherto prided itself on the fact that every man had a job - this was the
summary of Mr. Jones’s first-hand observations.”:
“Russia today is in the grip of a famine which is proving as disastrous as
the catastrophe of 1921 when millions died, reported Gareth Jones of Great
Britain, who arrived in Berlin this morning en route to London after a long
walking tour through the Ukraine and other districts in the Soviet Union.
“The arrest of the British engineers in Moscow is a symbol of panic in
consequence of conditions worse than in 1921. Millions are dying of
hunger. The trial, beginning Saturday, of the British engineers is merely a
pendant to the recent shooting of thirty-five prominent workers in
agriculture, including the Vice-Commissar of the Ministry of Agriculture,
and is an attempt to check the popular wrath at the famine which haunts
every district of the Soviet Union.”
Promptly in the New York Times[viii]
as though to pre-empt Gareth’s statement Walter Duranty issued a rebuttal,
but it was a rebuttal of classic Orwellian ‘doublespeak’: “Since I talked
with Mr. Jones I have made exhaustive inquiries about this alleged famine
situation. . . . There is serious food shortage throughout the country with
occasional cases of well-managed state or collective farms. The big cities
and the army are adequately supplied with food. There is no actual
starvation or death from starvation, but there is widespread is mortality
from diseases due to malnutrition.”
The
New York Times on May 13th,
1933
[ix] printed a reply from ‘Mr.
Jones’ to Walter Duranty’s article of March 31st in which
Gareth, in a letter to the newspaper, said he stood
by his statement that the Soviet Union was suffering from
a severe famine. Everywhere he went in the Russian villages he heard the
cry; “There is no bread, we are dying”. The censors had turned the
journalists into masters of euphemism and understatement and hence they gave
“famine” the polite name of “food shortage” and “starving to death” and
softened it to read as “widespread mortality from diseases due to
malnutrition”.
Further confirmation of the denigration of Gareth’s
press statement was made by Eugene Lyons in his 1937 book, Assignment in
Utopia[x].
It described how the Moscow Foreign Correspondents publicly denied
Gareth Jones’ portrayal of the shocking situation in Soviet Russia and
Ukraine, even after they had had queries from their home offices on the
subject of the famine. But these inquiries coincided with preparations that
were under way for the show-trial of some six British engineers. The need
to remain on friendly terms with the Soviet censors at least for the
duration of the trial was a compelling professional necessity.
This attempt to humiliate Gareth is well known, but
there is little to refer to in attempting to investigate the intrigues of
the political circles of the British establishment.[xi]
I have researched the archives of the persons that Gareth knew well during
the time he worked with David Lloyd George, the former Prime Minister of
World War One and find them to be mysteriously bare after 1933. Only Frances
Stevenson in her published Diaries[xii]
had written that she had heard of the death of a ‘dear friend’. From 1933
Lloyd George’s archives are strangely devoid of reference to him after
1933. Dr Thomas Jones who had been deputy private secretary to four Prime
Ministers and a close friend of Gareth’s father makes no reference to Gareth
and yet he quotes an anecdote that only appeared in a private letter to
Gareth’s family.[xiii]
A.J. Sylvester, secretary to Lloyd George avoids writing any reference to
Gareth despite describing an occasion when the latter accompanied him to
Bron-y-De, Churt, the ‘the Chief’’s home when the old man was ill.[xiv]
Later in this Biography about Lloyd George when referring to The War
Memoirs he leaves a name blank, but wrote that, “The latter had let him
down badly.”[xv]
I have no doubt that this refers to Gareth and the friendship that Lloyd
George had with Ambassador Maisky and Soviet Commissar Litvinov and the fact
that Gareth had written to the former Prime Minister that he was amazed that
he had such admiration for Stalin.
Did the British Government in view of the concurrent
international crisis silence Gareth? The young man was well known to Dr
Thomas Jones, a close friend of Stanley Baldwin[xvi]
and others of the Establishment including the Cliveden Set and no doubt
T.J.’s views were an influence on the British Cabinet. The government was
concerned with the recent rise of National Socialism in Germany and the
appointment Adolph Hitler as Chancellor. A further concern was Japan’s
designs for the territorial expansion in China and nearer home was the
plight of the six Metropolitan-Vickers engineers in Moscow. The friendship
of the Soviet Union was of high priority. The guilt of the British
Government that turned its eye away from the plight of the starving
Ukrainians has yet to be exposed.
What part did Maisky play in the vilification of
Gareth. Did he persuade the British Government to serve ‘D’ notice on the
honest journalist thus preventing him writing any more articles on the
man-made famine in British newspapers? On April 8th Sylvester
“was received by M. Maisky, (Ambassador of the Soviet Union to Great Britain
1932-1943) at twelve noon. Maisky was a “prominent figure in British
political scene and mixed extensively in opposition circles”[xvii].
Was Sylvester called to the Soviet Embassy to hear of the accusations
against Gareth on this day in April.’33?[xviii]
Gareth spent the following year in bosom of his family
working for the Cardiff newspaper The Western Mail. He wrote some
delightful articles about rural Wales and informative ones about the Irish
situation. Not until the following June did he write any political articles
which only referred to the rise of Nazism in Germany.
In October 1934 Gareth embarked on a “Round the World
Fact-Finding Tour”.[xix]
He spent three months in the USA and then six weeks in Japan. He continued
round what today is called the Pacific Basin and then proceeded to China
where he planned to investigate the intentions of the Japanese in the
north. His ‘Final Journey’ was made in a vehicle owned by the company,
Wostwag. This organization, dealing in furs, was a cover for the Soviet
Secret police in the Far East. Having wandered into Dolonor, a town in
Inner Mongolia, north China in which Japanese troops were massing, he and
his companion a German, Dr Herbert Mueller were captured by bandits, and
held for ransom for £8,000. The Japanese had told them there were two routes
to follow back to Kalgan, one of which was safe and the other infested by
bad bandits. Within two days of captivity the German was released, but 14
days later in the hands of the bandits, Gareth was murdered. Though the
suspicion falls on the Soviets there is no answer, as yet, as to who
actually killed Gareth.
Gareth Richard Vaughan Jones died in pursuit of truth
on the eve of his thirtieth birthday. |